Speech-Language Services in Public Schools: How Policy Ambiguity Regarding Eligibility Criteria Impacts Speech-Language Pathologists in a Litigious and Resource Constrained Environment

Lesley Sylvan, Ed.D, CCC-SLP

Harvard Graduate School of Education 



Public school districts must determine which students are eligible to receive special education and related services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA).  This study, which involves 39 interviews with speech-language pathologists and school administrators, examines how eligibility recommendations are made for one widely provided service: speech-language therapy.  A key finding of this study is that the policy infrastructure guiding eligibility decisions has areas of significant ambiguity leading SLPs to face uncertainty about who should be found eligible for speech-language services. This ambiguity in policy opens the door for economic and legal factors to detrimentally influence the eligibility determination process resulting in high numbers of eligible students and correspondingly large SLP caseloads. Specifically, the litigious environment in which school districts operate puts SLPs on the defensive in the eligibility determination process. Further, speech-language therapy is increasingly utilized as a safety net given the lack of other resources available to academically struggling public school students. Finally, SLPs receive little administrative support or supervision further exacerbating their vulnerability to external pressures when making eligibility decisions. While focusing specifically on the eligibility decision process for speech-language services, this paper highlights issues that are likely applicable to how eligibility decisions for special education services are made more broadly.


Read or Download Instructions

To Read this Article - Left Click Here (login required)

To Download this Article - Right Click Here (login required)
(choose "save", "save target as" or "save as")

To Download the Entire FALL 2014 Issue of JAASEP - Click Here  (login required)

AASEP MEMBERS LOGIN to Access live links to all available JAASEP issues.


Not a Member?

If you are a member of AASEP, please login to freely access this and all archived issues of JAASEP

If you are NOT A MEMBER of AASEP or NASET you may purchase this article from  the FALL 2014 issue of JAASEP for $4.95 (use the Buy Now button) or Join NASET for free access to this and all past issues of JAASEP on NASET.


Return to the Table of Contents - Click Here

To top